Measured differences only. Ties and tiny gaps are left out.
Why pick theENVY 6558e All-In-One Printer0 wins
No measured advantages in our spec data. Check the full specs below.
Check priceNo store price yet
Why pick theSmart Tank 51091 win
−1,110 gLighter in the hand5,030 vs 6,140 g
Check priceNo store price yet
Full specs
Side-by-side specifications
Connectivity1 difference
Image formats supported
JPG, PNG
JPG, PNG, TIFF
Software1 difference
Mac operating systems supported
Mac OS X 12.0 Monterey · Mac OS X 13.0 Ventura · Mac OS X 14.0 Sonoma
Mac OS X 10.15 Catalina · Mac OS X 10.15.3 Catalina · Mac OS X 11.0 Big Sur
Physical4 differences
Weight
6140 g
5030 g
Depth
361 mm
361.5 mm
Height
171 mm
157.3 mm
Width
433 mm
434.7 mm
Display2 differences
Screen size
6.1" (155 mm)
3.05" (77 mm)
Maximum copy resolution
300 x 300 DPI
600 x 600 DPI
Performance3 differences
Storage (max)
256 MB
64 MB
Sound power level (printing)
6 dB
6.4 dB
Processor frequency
800 MHz
980 MHz
Battery & charging4 differences
Sleep power
1.9 W
1.096 W
Power consumption (off)
0.175 W
0.109 W
Power consumption (ready)
4.25 W
3.023 W
Power supply type
Built-in Universal Power Supply
Internal built in
Design11 differences
Colors
Beige
Blue
Colour name
Portobello
College Blue
Pallet dimensions (W x D x H) (imperial)
950 x 1080 x 2479 mm (37.4 x 42.5 x 97.6")
1218.9 x 1016 x 2389.9 mm (48 x 40 x 94.1")
Print speed (colour, draft quality, A4/US Letter)
17 ppm
16 ppm
Print speed (colour, normal quality, A4/US Letter)
7 ppm
5 ppm
Print speed (ISO/IEC 24734) colour
7 ppm
5 ppm
Time to first page (colour, normal)
22 s
21 s
Pallet dimensions (W x D x H)
950 x 1080 x 2479 mm
1200 x 1000 x 2390 mm
Pallet gross weight
493 kg
432 kg
Pallet weight (imperial)
492.1 kg (1085 lbs)
430.9 kg (950 lbs)
Sustainable technologies and materials
Recyclable through HP Planet Partners
45% post-consumer recycled plastic · ENERGY STAR certified · EPEAT registered
General32 differences
Box contents
HP Envy 6558e All-in-One Printer · HP 68 Setup Black Cartridge · HP 68 Setup Tri-Color Cartridge
HP Smart Tank 5109 All-in-One Printer · HP 32XL 135-ml Black Original Ink Bottle · HP 31 50-ml Cyan Original Ink Bottle
Included cartridge capacity (black)
120 pages
6000 pages
Included cartridge capacity (CMY)
75 pages
6000 pages
Certification
CISPR 32:2012 / EN 55032:2012 Class B CISPR 32:2015 / EN 55032:2015 Class B CISPR 24:2010 / EN 55024:2010 CISPR 35:2016 / EN 55035:2017 FCC CFR 47 Part 15 Class B ICES-003, Issue 6 VCCI-CISPR 32:2016 EN 301 489-1 V2.1.1:2017 EN 301 489-17 V3.1.1:2017
CISPR 32 2015+A1:2019 Class B/EN 55032:2015+A11:2020 Class B
Compatible operating systems
Windows 11 · Windows 10 · macOS 12 Monterey
Windows 11 · Windows 10 · macOS 10.15 Catalina
Maximum duty cycle
1000 pages per month
3000 pages per month
Number of print cartridges
2
4
Recommended duty cycle
100 - 400 pages per month
400 - 800 pages per month
Control Type
Touch
Buttons
Custom media length
127 - 304.8 mm
127 - 355.6 mm
Custom media width
76.2 - 216 mm
88.9 - 215.9 mm
Envelopes sizes
B5, C6, DL
B5, DL
ISO A-series sizes (A0...A9)
A4, A5, A6
A4, A6
Custom media sizes
Simplex: 76.2 x 127 mm to 216 x 304.8 mm; Duplex: 76.2 x 127 mm to 216 x 297 mm
88.9 x 127 to 215.9 x 355.6 mm
Electromagnetic compatibility
CISPR 32:2012 / EN 55032:2012 Class B CISPR 32:2015 / EN 55032:2015 Class B CISPR 24:2010 / EN 55024:2010 CISPR 35:2016 / EN 55035:2017 FCC CFR 47 Part 15 Class B ICES-003, Issue 6 VCCI-CISPR 32:2016 EN 301 489-1 V2.1.1:2017 EN 301 489-17 V3.1.1:2017
CISPR 32 2015+A1:2019 Class B/EN 55032:2015+A11:2020 Class B
Manufacturer warranty
One-Year limited hardware warranty with option to extend to two-years with acceptance of HP+ Offer. For more info please visit us at http://support.hp.com .
One-year or 30
Recommended humidity operating range
25 - 75%
20 - 80%
Recommended system requirements
Microsoft Windows 11
Windows 11 · Windows 10 · 1 GHz processor
Direct printing
No
Yes
Duplex printing mode
Auto
Manual
Print speed (black, draft quality, A4/US Letter)
20 ppm
22 ppm
Print speed (black, normal quality, A4/US Letter)
10 ppm
12 ppm
Print speed (ISO/IEC 24734) black
10 ppm
12 ppm
Time to first page (black, normal)
19 s
14 s
HP GTIN (EAN/UPC)
196,068,649,944
198,828,752,772
HP Security tools
Yes
No
Layers per pallet
6 pc(s)
5 pc(s)
Master (outer) cases per pallet layer
10 pc(s)
12 pc(s)
Maximum output capacity
25 sheets
30 sheets
Total output capacity
25 sheets
30 sheets
Maximum internal memory
256 MB
64 MB
Sustainability certificates
ENERGY STAR, EPEAT
ENERGY STAR, EPEAT Silver
Where to buy
Specs verified against manufacturer data. Prices in USD before tax; we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases.
Community
Which would you buy?
One vote per person. Results appear after you vote.
Why pick theENVY 6558e All-In-One Printer0 wins
Why pick theSmart Tank 51091 win